The doctrine of colourable legislation means if the constitution of a state distributes the legislative spheres marked out by specific legislative entries or if there are limitations on the legislative authority in the shape of fundamental rights, questions do arise as to whether the legislature in a particular case has not, in respect to the subject matter of the statute or in the method of enacting it, transgressed the limits of the constitutional power. Introduction with the enactment of laws by different legislative bodies all over the world, conflict of laws is an unavoidable issue. The literal meaning of colorable legislation is that under the color or guise of power conferred for one particular purpose, the legislature. This site additionally contains content derived from eurlex, reused under the terms of the commission decision 2011833eu on the reuse of documents from the eu institutions. National endowment for the arts 400 7th street, sw, washington, dc 20506 202. Many of you may be familiar with the doctrine of basic structure. Yes, the doctrine of colourable legislation any be applied to a constitutional amendment act. Pith and substance is a legal doctrine in canadian constitutional interpretation used to determine under which head of power a given piece of legislation falls. Money bill, doctrine of pith and substances, doctrine of. What do you mean by colourable exercise of power in. The doctrine of colourable legislation is based upon the maxim that you cannot do indirectly what you cannot do directly. Balsara this is the first important judgment of the supreme court that took recourse to the doctrine of pith and substance. Short speech on the doctrine of colourable legislation. Thus the whole doctrine of colourable legislation is based upon the maxim that you cannot do indirectly what you cannot do directly.
However, there are deficiencies in language itself, in human foresight, and in the ability to express ideas. Legislation may be regarded as colourable when a legislature having no power to legislate. As far as indian judiciary is concerned, there are many doctrines. Ii violation of fundamental rights part iii or any other constitutional requirement or limitation like for eg. The legislature can only make laws within its legislative competence.
The court upheld the doctrine of pith and substance and said that it is important to ascertain the true nature and character of a legislation for the purpose of determining the list under which it falls. Indian judicial doctrines principles of constitutional. The importance of open legal data is made powerfully by people like carl malamud and the law. Doctrine of basic structure the basic structure doctrine is an indian judicial principle that. In this book he defined the principle of utility as that property in any object whereby it tends to produce pleasure, good or happiness, or to prevent the happening of mischief. While the national policy on urban street vendors, 2009 handed out the responsibility for its implementation and appropriate legislation to the states, the svb is a response to a longfelt need for central legislation that would recognise the contribution of street vendors and provide uniformity in legal framework across the country. Principles of legislative drafting 3 2 every word has meaning this principle assumes that every word of an enactment is intended to have legal effect. All content is available under the open government licence v3. She has discussed the different doctrines under the indian constitution in detail. The doctrine does not involve any question of bonafides or malafides intention on the part of the legislature. Thus in order to put more light and certainty the doctrine of repugnancy came in to picture as a principle, which is employed so as to ascertain when and where a state law turns repugnant to the parliamentary legislation. The context if the relevant text of the legislation can be interpreted in different ways, other features of the legislation can be used to clarify but not distort the meaning such as the title, headings, structure and surrounding sections.
Doctrine of equivalents and doctrine of colourable variation. Again, as an introduction to the principles of legislation in general, it ought rather to have included matters belonging exclusively to the civil branch, than matters more particularly applicable to the penal. Be it enacted by the senate and house of representatives of the united states of america in congress assembled, that this act may be cited as the national science foundation act of 1950. This article is written by khushi agrawal, 1styear student, symbiosis law school, noida. What is pivotal is the fact that the legislature usually this is associated with state legislature does not possess the power to make law upon a particular aspect but nonetheness indirectly makes one. Legislation will not say anything that it has already said. The transgression is veiled by mere pretense or disguise. Thus, it refers to the competency of the legislature to enact a particular.
The whole doctrine resolves itself into the question of competency of a particular legislature to enact a particular law. Constitutional law doctrine of colorable legislation and the constitution of india introduction doctrine of colorable legislation like any other constitutional law doctrine is a tool devised and applied by the supreme court of india to interpret various constitutional provisions. Doctrine of colorable legislation you cannot do indirectly what you cannot do directly. Considers whether uk legislation that is identified as being constitutional should be interpreted in a special way and, if so, what interpretative techniques should be used. In such case, although the legislation purports to act within the limits of its powers, yet in substance and in reality, it transgresses those powers. This doctrine was first applied in india by justice porter, in prafulla. It comes to know while the legislature purporting to act within its power but in reality it has transgressed those powers. Constitutional law doctrine of colorable legislation. Legislation 2018 this document contains a summary of legislation relevant to the policy priorities and professional practice of the kansas academy of family physicians.
Legislation statute law is written law enacted by a body or person authorised to do so by the constitution or other legislation. Therefore, achieving an unauthorised purpose will be a colourable exercise of power subject to be declared illegal by the courts. Unlike the design law, the patents law does not specify as to what would constitute infringement of a patented product or process. Discusses the approaches used to interpret ordinary legislation and how constitutional provisions are interpreted in other jurisdictions. The doctrine of colorable legislation means if the constitution of a state distributes the legislative spheres marked out by specific legislative entries or if there are limitations on the legislative authority in the shape of fundamental rights, questions do arise as to whether the legislature in a particular case has not, in respect to the subject matter of the statute or in the method of.
The doctrinaire trident testing constitutionality of the laws. The doctrine thus refers to the question of competence of the legislature concerned to enact. Doctrine of colourable legislation prevents legislatures. Principles of constitutional interpretation acknowledgment. Constitutional law doctrine of colorable legislation and. Guide to legislation and legislative process in british columbia august 20 part 2. Money billa money bill and financial bill money bill involving some other matter also differ from other bills in that these can be introduced in the house of people and that also with the recommendation of the president. The letters of the constitution are fairly static and not very easy to change but the laws enacted by the legislature reflect the current state of people and are very dynamic. The question whether a law is a colourable legislation and as such void, does not depend on the motive or bona fides of the legislature in passing the law but upon the competency of the legislature to pass that particular law, and what the courts have to determine in such. Short essay on the doctrine of colourable legislation.
In this case is the court will look in the true nature and character of the legislation and for that its object, purpose or design to make the law on a subject is relevant and not its motive. Legislation may be regarded as colourable when a legislature having no power to legislate frames a legislation so camouflaging the same as to. A knowledge of these, makes the legislator appreciate the moral and legal philosophies of bentham and also to get an insight into the sociology of law. This is part 2 of the doctrines of the indian constitution, this lesson deals with 2 doctrines that is doctrine of repugnancy, and doctrine of colourable legislation. The whole doctrine of colourable legislation is based upon the maxim that you cannot do indirectly what you cannot do directly. If the legislature is competent to pass a particular law. Vijay sardana advocate, delhi high court this doctrine is based on the principle that what cannot be done directly cannot be done indirectly. In preference therefore, or at least in priority, to the.
In india the doctrine of colorable legislation signifies only a limitation of the law making power of the legislature. If, in fact, it has power to make the law, its motives in making the latter are irrelevant. Thus, it refers to the competency of the legislature to enact a particular law. Watch the full video first so that you develop an understanding of. Doctrine of colourable legislation the doctrine of colourable legislation does not involve any question of bona fides or mala fides on the part of the legislature. The doctrine of colourable legislation is based on the maxim that what cannot be done directly cannot also be done indirectly. Doctrine of colorable legislation like any other constitutional law doctrine is a tool devised and applied. The doctrine of colourability is the idea that when a legislature wants to do something that it cannot do within the constraints of its governments constitution, it colours the law with a substitute purpose, allowing it to accomplish its original goal. As the assignments listed below indicate, we will cover most of the book, at a pace of about 5060 pages a week. Doctrine of pith and substance, doctrine of colourable legislation. In this article, we will be dealing all important indian judicial doctrines. In simpler terms it means indirectly doing something which cannot be done directly.
The doctrinaire trident testing constitutionality of the laws by. The doctrine of legitimate expectation and the limit of its application in current indian law would also be examined as well as the scope for further broadening of the doctrine under indian law. Rent legislation and regulation 2nd edition 9781609302177 and save up to 80% on textbook rentals and 90% on used textbooks. Watch the full video first so that you develop an understanding of the topic and make notes while watching. Legislation must be distinguished from other types of law because the rules and principles of statutory. Be it enacted by the senate and house of representatives of. Legislation and regulation 2nd edition rent 9781609302177. The question of colourable legislation was fully discussed by the supreme court in k. Doctrine of colourable legislation, like any other constitutional law doctrine, is a tool devised and applied by the supreme court of india to interpret various constitutional provisions. What could be the limitations of the application of doctrine. This doctrine basically says that what cannot be done directly cannot also be done indirectly. Legislation is one of the most important instruments of government in organising society and protecting citizens. In this case is the court will look in the true nature and character of the legislation and for that its object, purpose or design to make the law. The doctrine of colourable legislation is based on the principle that what cannot be done directly cannot be done indirectly.
The doctrine of colourable legislation, which tests the competence of legislature against an enacted law, is. Sections 104114 of the patents act, 1970 provide guidelines relating to patent infringement. Such legislation or law is called colourable legislation. It is to this later class of transgression that the doctrine of colourable legislation applies. What could be the limitations of the application of. Current issues in the interpretation of federal legislation. Atome scan of national legislation the research leading to these results has received funding from the european communitys seventh framework programme fp72007. The doctrine of colourable legislation refers to the question of competency of the legislature while enacting a provision of law. Principles of morals and legislation jeremy bentham glossary affection.
Pdf the doctrinaire trident testing constitutionality of the laws. The doctrine is applied to determine whether a legislation is within the. Legislation and regulation syllabus professor bruff fall 2012 readings. Our desire to make the statute book available as open data motivated a number of technology choices we made. Principles of constitutional interpretation introduction. A guide to legislation and legislative process in british. Principles of constitutional interpretation law and beyond. Thus it refers to the question of competency of the legislature to enact a particular law or to amend the consitution. Doctrine of colourable legislation would come within this as it is essentially a question of power. The doctrine becomes applicable when a legislature seeks to do something in an indirect manner when it cannot do it directly. Miscellaneous topics in india polity by sai samir badeti. Jan 14, 2017 doctrine of colorable legislation india.
This paper examines the origins and rationale of the concept of legitimate expectation. In the early modern period, affection could mean fondness, as it does today. However, we have seen that if the legislation is in pith and substance within the scope of its allotted field, and the exceeding of the power is only in regard to. Statutory interpretation and constitutional legislation. The doctrine of colourable legislation is relevant only in connection with the question of legislative competence. Doctrine of colorable legislation like any other constitutional law doctrine is a tool devised and applied by the supreme court of india to interpret various constitutional provisions. Doctrine of colorable legislation and fraud on constitution. The doctrine of colourable legislation has nothing to do with the motive of the legislation, it is in the essence a question of vires or power of the legislature to enact the law in question. The doctrine of pith and substance is otherwise known as the doctrine of. Summary of legislation oregon legislative assembly. Challenge to subordinate legislation all grounds on which a plenary legislation. Oct 21, 2010 to examine whether a legislation has impinged on the field of other legislatures, in fact or in substance, or is incidental, keeping in view the true nature of the enactment, the courts have evolved the doctrine of pith and substance for the purpose of determining whether it is legislation with respect to matters in one list or the other. Distribution of legislative powers under the indian. The doctrine of stare decisis or precedents is the distinguishing characteristic of the english common law.
The doctrine of colourability is the idea that when a legislature wants to do something that it. Therefore, if the authority fails to furnish a reasonable explanation for the delay, the subjective satisfaction may be inferred to be colourable and not genuine. Doctrine of repugnancy in india essay example ozziessay. Interpretation of legislation 319 needed no interpretation. The effect of interpretation is to make the law real by giving definition and meaning to statutes. A doctrine is a belief, principle or position usually upheld by authorities like courts. An introduction to the principles of morals and legislation. When the question of the validity of such law arises before the courts, they apply the doctrine of colourable legislation and declare the law as invalid. On the principles of drafting itself, benthams work may be said to be the starting point from which the modern theory of legislative drafting is derived. In india doctrine of colourable legislation signifies only a limitation of the law making power of the legislature. On one view, tonights topic assumes that current issues in interpreting federal legislation differ in some way from those arising with respect to state and territory legislation.
The doctrine of colourable legislation means if the constitution of a state distributes the legislative spheres marked out by specific legislative entries or if there are limitations on the legislative authority in the shape of fundamental rights, questions do arise as to whether the legislature in a particular case has not, in respect to. What the sc will have to consider while examining the centres move. Doctrines are a rule, principle, theory, or tenet of the law. My project has two different parts, the part one of my work deal with the doctrine of colourable legislation and part two deals with legislative accountability. Paper ii constitutional law of india ii structure and. In order to ascertain the true character of the legislation one must have regard to the. The doctrine is primarily used when a law is challenged on the basis that one level of government be it provincial or federal has encroached upon the exclusive jurisdiction of another level of government. Very short answer is required not exceeding 75 words.
The doctrine becomes applicable when a legislature seeks to do something in an indirect manner what it cannot do directly. In other words, it is the substance of the act that is material and not merely the form or outward appearance, and if the subject matter is substance which is beyond the whole doctrine of colourable legislation is based upon the maxim that you cannot do indirectly what you cannot do directly. Administrative power cannot be used for the purpose it was not given. Sep 05, 2017 doctrine of colourable legislation the doctrine of colourable legislation does not involve any question of bona fides or mala fides on the part of the legislature. Law notes on principles of constitutional interpretation.
There is hereby established in the executive branch of the government an. As such, law made by judges when interpreting legislation is not established forever as the law but subject to later change or development. It is a guiding principle of immense utility while construing provisions relating to legislative competence. The question whether a law is a colourable legislation and as such void, does not depend on the motive or bona fides of the legislature in passing the law but upon the competency of the legislature to pass that particular law, and what the courts have to determine in such cases is whether, though the. On the other hand, a law has little or no value if there is neither discipline nor enforcement. Doctrine of colourable legislation prevents legislatures to make laws that they would otherwise not be able to create given the constitutional contraints. The use of language in legislation, like any other use of language, may.
504 675 254 794 733 555 1041 933 586 1374 13 419 716 692 1429 85 879 622 1512 182 1090 1004 1293 707 1326 681 263 1460 1059 788 95 601 1114 937 896 1056 3 588 1225 919